Cover and title pages

Małgorzata Smogorzewska

Publisher

Dorota Siudowska-Mieszkowska

Editorial coordinator

Renata Ziółkowska

Editor

Bogna Piotrowska

Production coordinator

Mariola Iwona Keppel

Reviewer

Prof. dr hab. Teresa Taranko, Szkoła Główna Handlowa w Warszawie

Prof. dr hab. Jan W. Wiktor, Uniwersytet Ekonomiczny w Krakowie

The publication has been co-financed with the National Science Center, 2015/17/B/HS4/00309

Copyright © by Wydawnictwo Naukowe PWN SA

Warszawa 2019

ISBN 978-83-01-20608-6

Wydawnictwo Naukowe PWN SA

02-460 Warszawa, ul. Gottlieba Daimlera 2

tel. 22 69 54 321; fax: 22 69 54 288

helpline 801 33 33 88

e-mail: pwn@pwn.com.pl; reklama@pwn.pl

www.pwn.pl

The book that you have purchased is the work of its author and publisher. Please respect their rights. You may make this book available free of charge to your family and friends, but do not publish it on the net. If you quote excerpts from it, do not change the original and always be sure to mention where they come from. And if you copy parts of it, do so only for your own use.

It is imperative that we respect other people’s rights and property.

See more on www.legalnakultura.pl.

Polska Izba Książki

eBook based on printed edition from year 2019, (1st ed.)

eBook created for Polish Scientific Publishers PWN by Monika Lipiec/Woblink

About the Author

dr hab. Małgorzata Bartosik-Purgat – a professor at Poznań University of Economics and Business.

Her research interests focus primarily on the cultural aspects of international business, consumer behavior in the international market, new media in marketing communication and international business strategies.

Contents

Introduction

1. Marketing communication in the light of Internet development – theoretical background

1.1. The communication process – the essence, elements and their meaning

1.2. The essence of marketing communication – a definitional approach

1.3. Types of marketing communication in a model approach

1.3.1. Characteristics of B2B and B2C markets in the aspect of marketing communication

1.3.2. Marketing communication models in B2B and B2C markets

1.4. Forms of marketing communication

1.4.1. Types and essence of forms of marketing communication

1.4.2. Forms of marketing communication in B2B and B2C markets

1.5. Computer-mediated communication theory in the context of selected communication theories

2. New media as the environment of marketing communication

2.1. World 3.0 in the context of Internet development

2.2. The nature and characteristics of new media

2.3. Social media as a type of new media

2.3.1. The essence and meaning of social media

2.3.2. The characteristics and functions of social media

2.3.3. Types of social media in the light of selected classifications

2.4. The possibilities of using new media in marketing communication – theoretical approach

2.4.1. Theoretical basis for the use of new technologies from the perspective of individual users – technology acceptance model

2.4.2. The use of new media in marketing strategies of enterprises – new marketing concepts

2.5. Possibilities of using new media in marketing communication of enterprises in B2B and B2C markets

3. Determinants of the use of new media in the processes of internationalization of enterprises

3.1. Classification of determinants of the use of new media in international marketing communication

3.2. Endogenous determinants

3.2.1. The degree of internationalization of the company

3.2.2. The size of the company

3.2.3. The type of products offered by the company

3.3. Exogenous determinants

3.3.1. Economic factors

3.3.2. Technological factors

3.3.3. Demographic factors

3.3.4. Cultural factors

3.3.5. Political and legal factors

4. New media and the effectiveness and efficiency of marketing communication

4.1. The effects of marketing communication – an attempt at identification

4.2. Effects, efficiency and effectiveness of marketing communication in the dimension of the entire company’s operation – interpretive dilemmas

4.3. Measuring the effectiveness and efficiency of marketing communication – methods and indicators

4.4. Effectiveness and efficiency of marketing communication in social media – measurement issues

5. New media in marketing communication and the effects of business activity in the international market – research assumptions

5.1. Research methodology

5.1.1. Research questions, main objective and specific objectives

5.1.2. The scope of research and research hypotheses

5.1.3. Research method and sampling

5.2. Determinants of the use of new media in marketing communication in the international market – a scheme of dependencies

5.3. Characteristics of the research sample

6. New media in marketing communication of the studied enterprises in B2B markets – results of empirical research

6.1. Types of new media in the communication of the studied enterprises with a foreign business partner

6.2. Determinants of using new media in communication with a foreign business partner by the studied companies

6.3. Characteristics of new media and the scope of their use by the studied enterprises in communication with a foreign business partner

7. New media in marketing communication of studied enterprises in B2C markets – results of empirical research

7.1. New media in the communication of studied enterprises with foreign business partners

7.1.1. Types of new media

7.1.2. Exogenous and endogenous determinants in the use of new media

7.1.3. Characteristics of new media and the scope of their use

7.2. New media in the communication with a mass audience in international market

7.2.1. Types of new media

7.2.2. Exogenous and endogenous determinants

7.2.3. Characteristics of new media and the effects of their use

7.2.4. Relations between the use of new media in communication and endogenous and exogenous factors – a summary

8. The significance of new media in international communication – case studies

8.1. Kukliki Felt Design Studio

8.2. TOPMET Light

8.3. Beiersdorf Manufacturing Poznań Sp. z o.o.

8.4. LUG Light Factory Sp. z o.o.

8.5. Avella Sp. z o.o.

8.6. Advanced Graphene Products Sp. z o.o.

8.7. The significance of new media in international communication – summary of case studies

Conclusion

Bibliography

Appendices

Footnotes

Introduction

Communication is the basic element leading to the achievement of the intended goals of entrepreneurs. Its significance increases along with the development of entities and their foreign expansion. As a result, the scope and diversity of the communication process and its elements are growing. In the case of communication with entities from other cultural circles, different values, symbols or ways of providing information should also be taken into account as they often play a fundamental role in successful negotiations or cooperation with a foreign partner.

Two types of communication can be distinguished. The first one – interpersonal communication – accompanies, in particular, B2B (business-to-business) entities, where discussions take place between representatives of cooperating enterprises or other institutions. The second type of communication is connected with the B2C (business-to-consumer) market, where the sender of the message is an institutional entity (e.g. an enterprise – a manufacturer of final goods), and its recipients – individual customers (potential buyers of these goods).

The importance of communication is constantly increasing. First of all, the continuous development of the Internet, new technologies and the emergence of more and more diverse communication tools in the market have a major impact on this. Secondly, the growing needs and changing requirements of counterparties and individual buyers require constant monitoring. It is connected with the necessity of multiplication of traditional and new communication solutions that contribute to the constant tracking of information from customers, introduction of changes, improvements and adjustments in the scope of marketing activities of enterprises. The growing number of media outlets used by buyers also makes it necessary to constantly monitor transmitted information, as negative feedback can very quickly affect the reputation of the company in the market, and a quick response may alleviate the escalation of the problem.

Changing the needs, preferences and attitudes of recipients is an important factor related to the development of new forms of communication. Equally important are the emergence and acceptance of new technological solutions in the area of communication. An important role is played by the development of new media, which, due to their specific nature, facilitate communication (it is much faster, becomes more direct and costs less than traditional forms of communication) with entities from both domestic market and distant foreign markets.

New media have become popular tools used in both interpersonal and marketing communication. The diversity of their forms makes almost every market participant (both individual and institutional) a user of at least one communication tool included in the new media, e.g. social networking sites, instant messengers or websites. The importance of new media can be proved by the statements that appeared in the largest economic journals in the first decade of the 21st century. In 2005, Business Week wrote that: social media is the biggest change since the industrial revolution, while a few months later The Economist published a text saying that: companies that do not understand digital communities will die (Smith, Zook 2016, p. 11).

The scope of implementation of modern solutions in communication is very high. Furthermore, they are constantly evolving and shaping the market (preferences and behavior of entities). In this context, increasing access to the Internet around the world and related tools contribute to combining traditional and modern solutions as far as the functioning of market entities is concerned (Kemp 2017). This situation stimulates the development of theoretical concepts, models or solutions in the area of communication, taking into account new market conditions and opportunities, e.g. computer mediated communication theory or technology acceptance model. In the area of marketing, on the other hand, strategies known as, for example, marketing 4.0 (Kotler, Kartajaya, Setiawan 2017), 360 degree marketing, social media marketing (SMM), inbound and outbound marketing, electronic word-of-mouth marketing (e-WoMM) and others are developed. They are a combination of “traditional” forms of communication with changes resulting from the development of new technologies that affect rapid change in tastes and preferences of buyers. In the 21st century, the nature of communication is changing, particularly in the B2C market, where the unilateral monolog of enterprises is transformed into a dialog with a potential purchaser.

Such a situation is possible due to the rapid development of the Internet and the specificity of communication tools operating thanks to it (including new media). They enable dialog both among individual purchasers of goods and with the participation of enterprises. New media are also used to collect information before purchasing a specific product, and contact between a potential buyer and an enterprise is becoming the last, rather than the first stage in making a purchase decision.

These changes also make it necessary to adapt the behavior of producers, which according to Scott (2014) should consist of “not disturbing the customer in their purchases”. What is more, the differences in behavior and needs between generations, where the Generations Y and Z are almost entirely dependent on access to the Internet and smartphones, necessitate the adaptation of marketing solutions taking into account the latest technologies. That is why marketing and IT specialists very often cooperate intensively and even create joint departments in enterprises (Marketing Team Structures Report 2017).

The importance of new media in the communication of entities increases with degree of their use, which is visible in all market models and the nature of relations between entities. Both in communication between institutional units – B2B, institutional and individual customers – B2C, individual entities – C2C (consumer-to-consumer), as well as individual final buyers and institutional buyers – C2B (consumer-to-business) (Hüther 2016).

Marketing communication and the possibility of using new media in it plays an important role especially in B2C and B2B markets. It is based on the use of diverse media and business models due to different characteristics of the markets and their participants. In the B2B market, there is a significant degree of interpersonal communication (between representatives of institutional entities). In the B2C market, on the other hand, communication is both interpersonal and mass, e.g. between enterprises and individual purchasers.

The main objective of the monograph is to identify the significance of new media tools in international communication (international communication is understood as communication between entities from disparate foreign markets), the effects achieved through their use, as well as factors influencing the degree of their use. The particular emphasis is placed on two types of market relations – B2B and B2C communication. The combination of the role of new media in communication in these areas is not an issue widely presented in the literature on the subject.

Literature studies and primary pilot study, conducted by the author of the monograph, have shown that the nature of communication depends on the characteristics of the entities participating in it. In the B2B market, these are in particular the relations between institutional entities represented by their representatives. B2C market includes both institutional entities (e.g. enterprises) as well as individual customers (e.g. potential buyers of goods). New media and their use in marketing communication in the international market are the subject of discussion in the monograph. On the other hand, the subject in primary research are enterprises operating in foreign markets.

The thematic scope of the monograph is interdisciplinary, combining such areas as economics, international marketing, cultural anthropology, as well as sociology and psychology. The substantial part of the secondary sources of information are publications in the form of scientific monographs and articles in Polish and foreign journals. Due to the nature of the discussed issues and their constant development, a significant part of these sources are also publications in Internet journals, as well as the latest reports and compilations presenting the discussed issues.

Primary research, which was developed as part of author’s own scientific research on the role of new media in international marketing communication, was conducted among both Polish and foreign enterprises (B2B and B2C), based in Poland, which also operate in the international market. The concept of triangulation of research methods based on the use of various methodological perspectives in research (Denzin 2006, Flick 2011, Czakon 2013) was used in this part, including: individual interview using a standardized questionnaire (as a quantitative method) and in-depth interview (as a qualitative research method). Case studies were developed on the basis of qualitative research. The research procedure was presented in detail in the fifth chapter.

The monograph consists of eight chapters. The first three chapters are theoretical in nature and are the foundation of the deliberations as well as an introduction to the conduct of primary research. They were carried out as part of a research grant of the National Science Center, OPUS 9, No. 2015/17/B/HS4/00309. Their results and conclusions are presented in the empirical part.

The first chapter is an introduction to the theoretical foundations of communication, its types and conditions. Particular attention is paid to marketing communication, its specificity taking into account the division into B2B and B2C markets. It presents forms of communication that can be used by enterprises while considering the latest technological solutions.

The second chapter is devoted to new communication tools in the context of the development of the Internet. It describes the elements of the so-called world 3.0. distinguishing the specificity of the Internet environment, consumers and organizations. Then, the development of traditional and new media is outlined. The author’s original concept of 5C is presented, referring to the presentation of key features of new media.

Subsequently, the specificity, types, advantages and limitations of social media are described. The chapter analyzes the combination of new technological solutions and marketing activities of enterprises. The technology acceptance model is presented, followed by marketing concepts based on the development of new technologies and media. Finally, the significance of new media in the activities of enterprises in B2B and B2C markets is discussed. It has been developed on the basis of own research results and the achievements of other researchers.

The third chapter presents the determinants of the use of new media by companies in communication in the international market. These factors can be divided into exogenous, taken from the environment, and endogenous, i.e. dependent on the enterprise. The endogenous determinants include the degree of internationalization of enterprises, their size and type of products offered by them in the foreign markets. In the second group, the components of the economic, technological, cultural, political and legal environment are presented in the context of their influence on the possibilities and nature of using new media in communication. All these elements have been characterized in the context of their impact on the use of new media.

The fourth chapter focuses on the effectiveness and efficiency of marketing communication. At the beginning, the differences between the effects, efficiency and effectiveness of marketing activities, i.e. issues that are interpreted differently in the literature on the subject, are discussed. In this part of the monograph, in addition to presenting interpretative dilemmas, selected methods and indicators for measuring effectiveness and efficiency are presented. Furthermore, the problem of effectiveness and efficiency of marketing communication through social media is presented. The main emphasis is placed on theoretical and empirical models, including Bartholomew’s model, the Huyse model and others.

The fifth chapter of the monograph presents the methodology of own research, the main research assumptions of the empirical study and the stages of the research procedure. The objective of the research, research questions as well as hypotheses formulated on the basis of literature research, observations and own experiences are presented in detail. The triangulation of research methods resulting from the combination of quantitative and qualitative research methods is discussed. The studied population, sampling frame, and research sample are characterized. This chapter also presents the author’s original scheme showing endo- and exogenous determinants and the effects of using new media in communication activities in the foreign markets. The presented dependencies refer to formulated hypotheses, which were subjected to statistical testing, and its effects are presented in chapters 6 and 7.

Chapters 6 and 7 present the results of the “quantitative part of empirical research” concerning the importance of new media in international interpersonal communication with a foreign partner (B2B and B2C market) and marketing communication (B2C market). They include statistics on the influence of particular determinants on the use of new media, as well as its effects. These parts are concluded with a summary and discussion related to theoretical concepts. The results of statistical tests with the use of Spearman’s rank correlation, chi-squared test and Cramer’s V indicators showing the correlations presented in research hypotheses are also discussed.

The results of qualitative research are presented in chapter 8. The main research method consists of in-depth individual interviews conducted among selected individuals belonging to studied population. As a result of this research, six case studies (three from the B2B market and three from the B2C market of various sizes) are developed describing the importance of new media in international communication activities. The chapter is concluded with a summary and a reference to the results obtained in the quantitative part.

The monograph ends with a summary in which attention is focused on the applicability of the research results obtained and theoretical considerations carried out throughout the work. Reference is made to the enterprises diversified in terms of the type of products offered to foreign markets, the degree of their internationalization as well as their size. Furthermore, research limitations and proposals for their development in the future are also indicated.

1. Marketing communication in the light of Internet development – theoretical background

Sales promotion

Among the forms of the mix promotion, there are also tools for increasing the sales and customer loyalty to brands that are not included in the types of advertising described above. Mühlbacher, Leihs and Dahringer (2006) define sales promotion as short-term decisions and activities of the company within marketing communication, which aim to attract attention, stimulate interest, and motivate potential customers to buy products. In the source literature this kind of promotion is also called “additional promotion” or “complementary promotion” of advertising (Czinkota, Ronkainen 2007; Wiktor 2013), the main area of promotion.

One of the basic features of sales promotion, emphasized in many definitions, is the stimulation of purchase and an almost immediate effect in the form of a product purchase by a customer (Mühlbacher, Leihs and Dahringer 2006; Czinkota, Ronkainen 2007). Kotler (2004) states that “sales promotion consists of applying incentives and rewards, which encourage customers to buy now rather than later” (p. 152). Similarly, Czarnecki (2003) emphasizes the large, though short-lived effect of this type of promotion. In his opinion, the most appropriate stage for using such activities in a product life cycle is, first, the moment when it is introduced to the market (encouragement to buy and get to know the benefits), and then when it reaches maturity or even enters the phase of decline. Sales promotion tools are then designed to stimulate interest and purchase again.

Short-term operation of sales promotion, as incentives to buy, is also emphasized by Żbikowska and Potocki (2011), as well as other researchers in the publication Communicating in Marketing edited by Mruk (2004). According to the authors of the last position, sales promotion brings the best results when it is a part of IMC. In their opinion, sales promotion activities are complementary to advertising or PR, which bring results after a long time (Mruk 2004). Similar characteristics of sales promotion are distinguished by Wiktor (2013), pointing out that these tools “offer economic and psychological benefits” (p. 206), encourage quick purchasing decisions and, as a consequence, give almost immediate sales results.

The goals and functions of this mix promotion instrument result from the interpretation of sales promotion. The most important among them are:

- stimulating interest in the company, its products and brands, which may result in increased sales;

- testing new products – samples or tastings can be helpful in assessing new proposals appearing on the market, as well as interest in the offer;

- increasing off-season sales (for seasonal products or services), where effective price reductions or attractive gifts (additions to the product) may be effective;

- increasing customer loyalty – participation in loyalty programs may cause an increase in sales, thanks to re-visits of the store by customers (additional discounts for regular customers, rewards for internships, birthday gifts, etc.). Increased loyalty can also be achieved by invitations to stores when a new collection appears, offering substantive help to regular customers, advice or training.

The above features, goals and functions of sales promotion tools refer mainly to positive market effects. Some negative aspects of sales promotion should also be indicated, including:

- the possibility of increasing the buyers’ price sensitivity;

- with frequent promotions, products and brands can be seen on the market as cheap and low quality;

- costs incurred by the company in connection with promotional activities;

- the possibility of uneven sales (sale increases rapidly during the promotion, and significantly decreases after its completion – customers can “stock on” cheaper products).

In the light of the above elements, each situation should be well thought out and adapted to the market and expectations of its participants.

The variety of criteria allows distinguishing many types of sales promotions. One of them is the nature of the entities (auditorium) to which promotional activities are directed. Due to this element, the following activities are distinguished (see Table 5):

- Commercial promotion – it is most often used by producers in relation to intermediaries participating in the product distribution channel. For example, manufacturers provide samples or free products delivered to wholesalers or directly to retail stores, discounts on sales volumes, joint advertising, co-financing, etc.

- Consumer promotion – includes final buyers of products, which most often are individual entities. The following types of promotions should be distinguished: price promotions (periodic price cuts), free samples of goods, packaging bonuses (increased packaging for the unchanged price), gifts when purchasing a specific product (also known as a purchase bonus), participation in competitions and lotteries, tastings, refund offers (refund of part of the paid amount on showing proof of purchase), discount coupons (e.g. available in the press or other places), guarantees (e.g. extended warranty), trade stamps (their collection allows you to get a discount or a gift over a longer period of time), contests and lotteries, as well as many types of loyalty programs aimed at causing further purchases of products of a given brand.

- Promotion addressed to individual sellers (sales staff) – usually includes individual traders who have influence on the buyers’ choices. This type of sales promotion is also referred to as internal promotion, as it mostly concerns employees who are part of the company (B2B) or sales staff (B2C). This type of promotion distinguishes: remuneration systems, bonuses, business meetings (so-called events), contests, trainings, co-financing or even trips.

- Business promotion – aims to draw attention to the products of a given brand and to attract interest in the offer, i.e. fairs and exhibitions, advertising gadgets.

Table 5 presents selected sales promotion tools, their goals, as well as the entities which they are directed to.

Table 5. Selected sales promotion tools, their goals and recipients

Sales promotion tool

Target group

Goals

coupons

consumers/individual customers

stimulating the purchase process or encouraging re-purchase

discounts

consumers/individual customers

encouraging re-purchase

free samples

consumers/individual customers/intermediaries

stimulating the purchase process, building distribution, increasing orders

bonuses

consumers/individual customers

incentive to re-purchase

packaging bonuses

consumers/individual customers

stimulating the purchase process or encouraging re-purchase

contests and lotteries

consumers/individual customers/intermediaries/sales staff

stimulating the purchase process, increasing the number of orders

training

intermediaries/sales staff

providing information, improving sales skills

business meetings (events)

intermediaries/sales staff

providing information, improving sales skills/attracting attention

fairs and exhibitions

consumers/individual customers/intermediaries/sales staff

attracting attention/providing information/building distribution channels/stimulating purchases and orders

Source: (Mühlbacher, Leihs and Dahringer 2006).

Due to other elements of the socio-cultural and legal environment (Albaum, Duerr 2011), sales promotion instruments, like advertising messages, may differ on foreign markets (Keegan, Schlegelmilch 2001). Sales promotion tools, such as contests, lotteries and games, as well as attaching gifts to another product, are largely dependent on the law in a given country, e.g. in France they cannot exceed 7% of the value of the product to which thay are added (legislators consider that buyers should not buy gifts, only products) (Usunier, Lee 2009). However, collecting stamps, points and other instruments that after a certain period of time bring effects in the form of bonuses or price reductions, is more popular in cultures focused on achieving long-term goals, e.g. in Japan (Usunier, Lee 2009). In countries with short-term orientation, the preferred types of promotion allow to “feel” the effect of a promotional strategy immediately, e.g. in the “2 in 1” formula etc..

2. New media as the environment of marketing communication

2.1. World 3.0 in the context of Internet development

The beginnings of the development of the Internet refer to the 1970s. At the beginning, it was planned to create a network of information exchange among US scientists, later the project was to cover the whole world. This assumption quickly turned into a global information exchange platform not only for a specific group of people, but for the “average” inhabitant of the globe. Along with the increase in bandwidth and lowering the costs of using the Internet resources, it gained more and more users. The activity meant among other things the possibility of providing information by different users, e.g. by creating one’s own websites. This period on the development path of Internet was called Web 1.0. At that time, it was not possible to quickly exchange users’ opinions and conduct discussions on the web.

The development of the next stage of the Internet (see Figure 13) was a transition from a linear model, in which the website administrator could add Internet subpages, to a multidimensional model (Web 2.0), where the users of the network created content (e.g. by posting entries, commenting on other users’ entries, activity in social networks, etc.) by themselves.

Figure 13. Stages of Internet development

Source: own study based on (Pawlak, Nierebiński 2011; Aghaei, Nematbakhsh and Farsani 2012).

The concept of “Web. 2.0” was initially referred to as “the second version of the Internet”, which was created as a result of a technological breakthrough, and later as the way in which Internet users use Internet resources (Walkowska 2012). According to the latter, the Web 2.0 was an interactive social network that enabled collaboration between people who not only intensively used the Internet for work, study, shopping or entertainment, but also moved their activities, e.g. professional, to the Internet. The virtual world merged with the real world, and the reality began to be supported by the possibilities of the Internet.

The next stage of development of the Internet and tools made available thanks to it, is enabled by Web 3.0, where one can observe a more personalized offer in the context of individual users’ needs (e.g. selective data selection, contextual advertising). That is why Web 3.0 is called a semantic web, i.e. a network that reads the meaning of the needs of a particular individual. It must first receive the information, then collect it, and afterwards process it in order to generate an individualized data package. In other words, Web 3.0 fulfills the role of an intelligent provider (artificial intelligence) of selected information packages according to the interests of the recipient. In the concept of the semantic web, various applications and websites are able to “communicate” in order to gather relevant information and take specific actions. For example, after browsing websites with specific content, when the user moves to other websites, previously searched data may still be referenced to, for example in the form of information banners. Web 3.0 finds its basis in the semantic information theory, in which information is an aggregate of various messages, e.g. about product attributes or events. They allow taking specific actions, building opinions or taking a position on the case (Stefanowicz 1987).

In the literature there are also polemics about the next stage of development of the Internet, namely Web 4.0, that is the idea of a pragmatic web. In the concept and discussions about Web 4.0, an individual is referred to as an agent who possesses the ability to identify different schemes and communication systems. One that collects data available on the web, after previous instructions from users about their information needs. Web 4.0, as a pragmatic web, is designed to provide meaningful information about the application nature for the user. The information obtained on the basis of data available in the web will be able to take a variety of forms, e.g. statistical analysis, tables, comparisons, reports, etc. The concept of Web 4.0 is based on a pragmatic information theory founded on the analysis and assessment of cognitive factors and the usefulness of various data available in the organization. In the pragmatic theory of information, the access to and analysis of data provides the information necessary to make the right decisions (Gleick 2012).

The continuous development of the Internet and constantly evolving new technological solutions are related to changes in many areas of the functioning of individuals, organizations and institutions that govern the world. Access to information and a new type of communication also affect socio-cultural changes around the world. They consist in the access to knowledge, behavior of different nations, their preferences, possibilities, etc. Much of such information, coming from various markets, is transferred and implemented by individual units.

The source literature writes about the so-called revolution in the Information and Communication Technology (ICT) (Kelly 2001). According to the author, the breadth of cultural changes influences the fact that this term should be extended by another “c”. The second decade of the 21st century is characterized by a technological, cultural and communication revolution (TCC) with a dynamic course, which is referred to as the world 3.0. It consists, among other things, of four main elements (Figure 14):

- Web 3.0, which is the technological basis in which the Internet is used as a platform for services (new solutions) consisting, on the one hand, in personalization and, on the other hand, co-creation of content by recipients. Web 3.0 is sometimes referred to as the democratization of communication, where the boundary between its recipient and creator is blurred (power is in the hands of users). Furthermore, the Web 3.0 concept intends to make greater use of new technologies to discover the thoughts, feelings and emotions of their users – what are their feelings in a given place and time (Mróz 2016). For this purpose, social media can be used, mainly networking sites and instant messengers, which enable users to highlight emotions accompanying them at a specific time and place (e.g. Facebook allows a person to indicate their mood using built-in options that show that at a particular moment of e.g. sharing specific information or places, they are excited, proud or angry).

- Consumer 3.0 – it is the buyer/consumer using world 3.0 tools in their purchasing decisions and behaviors, i.e. mobile devices, as well as various types of Internet tools (including social media, online shopping, e-commerce). Consumer 3.0 eagerly searches for information about products and producers on websites, including social media (zero moment of truth, the ZMOT concept) (Linkiewicz, Bartosik-Purgat 2017). However, sometimes the final decision is made at the offline point of sale, which is described in the literature as the ROPO effect (research online, purchase offline). In a sense, it has become a “mode” of the construction defined earlier in the characteristics of the technological, cultural, and communication revolution (TCC).

Figure 14. Elements of World 3.0

Source: own study based on (Ghemawat 2015).

4.3. Measuring the effectiveness and efficiency of marketing communication – methods and indicators

Referring to theoretical considerations on the effectiveness and efficiency of enterprises, the measurement of the efficiency of marketing communication will be presented in the “objectives – effects (results, outputs) – outlays (inputs)” relation. The specificity of selected indicators of effectiveness and efficiency of marketing communication used for its measurement is presented below.

The basic indicator showing and measuring the efficiency of marketing communication activities (EMCA, Polish: EDKM) is the one that takes into account the relationship between economic effects and financial outlays (Taranko 2015):

Efficient activities can be described when the counter of the above fraction (effects) is greater than its denominator (financial outlays). Estimating both the effects and outlays for communication activities is one of the extremely difficult activities resulting from the separation of this activity from the general activity of the enterprise. Furthermore, these effects are very often intangible in nature and it is difficult to estimate their financial value. Taranko (2015) gives as an example the use of marketing communication tools for building the corporate image or maintaining good customer relationships. Thjomoe, Olson and Bronn (2002) came to similar conclusions, analyzing companies that incorporate sponsoring in their marketing activities. The surveyed entities had a sense of well-invested money in this type of activity, but only approximately 1/3 of them measured them economically.

Difficulties in measurable measurement and determination of the general level of efficiency of marketing communication activities result in the fact that few enterprises undertake this task. The results of research conducted by Forrester and ITSMA in 2013 confirm that the most frequent activity in the field of efficiency measurement is the preparation of reports that present operational results concerning, e.g. the number of page views, the range of exposure, advertising consumption, etc. The efficiency of marketing communication in relation to the presentation of economic (business) results in the form of e.g. measurement of market share, return on marketing investment or measurement of the impact of communication tools on customer loyalty is much less frequently examined (as cited in: Karpińska-Krakowiak 2015).

Reports on the activity of enterprises and the results of scientific research indicate that the measurements of the efficiency of communication activities is separated due to the tool used. Entities much more often use, for example, analyses of the impact of advertising or sales promotion tools on total sales than measure all marketing activities (including communication).

Measuring the effectiveness of marketing communication is a smaller problem for entities using its tools in their operations. It results from the essence of the term, i.e. the degree of achieving the intended goals/effects (see Figure 46), as illustrated in the following EsMCA (Polish: SDKM) relation: